Thursday, October 4, 2012

Making Sense of MOOCs - 20 page report by distinguished HE - Aiqus

Some more tidbits:

...A group of 6.002x students have created their own version of the follow-up course, 6.003, Signals and Systems, using material from MIT?s OpenCourseware site.

...Athabasca University Press (2012), a publisher of prize-winning academic books, has established the curious fact that ?putting a scholar?s book on the web to be read for free increases both sales and citation impact?.

...the Academic Partnerships (AP) programme launched in 2008 by Best Associates, a merchant bank based in Dallas, Texas (Academic Partnerships, 2012a). So far, although it has global ambitions, AP works with some 20 public universities in the US (e.g. University of Arkansas at Jonesboro, University of Texas at Arlington, Lamar University). These institutions may be less prestigious than those flocking to the Coursera and Udacity platforms, but at least they have found a way of making money and achieving good degree graduation rates.

...In Siemens? words: ?our cMOOC model emphasises creation, creativity, autonomy and social networking learning. The Coursera model emphasises a more traditional learning approach through video presentations and short quizzes and testing. Put another way, cMOOCs focus on knowledge creation and generation whereas xMOOCs focus on knowledge duplication?.

...Although (the University of) Phoenix has engaged in dodgy business practices, it is likely that because it operates as a teaching-learning system the quality of its instruction is objectively better than the new wave of online xMOOCs. (note: I would like to see what definition of quality is being used here)

...what decides whether or not a student can obtain a degree is determined not by their mastery of the courses, but by the admissions process to the university. This is an untenable nonsense. To give but one example, the UK Open University, which has no academic admission requirements, has awarded over a million highly regarded degrees to its students. Entry to the Open University is easy; exit with a degree is difficult.

...Kolowich (2012b), using the example of the University of Maryland, has shown that ?students can expect to spend a minimum of $1,300 to convert the learning picked up in an xMOOC into three college credits. That is, of course, in addition to the hours and effort they sink into actually taking the xMOOC?.

...the open educational resources (OER) movement (UNESCO, 2012) to make knowledge the common property of humankind, and to find a business model that generates money for doing it. The business case for OER is developing nicely and OER will transform the availability of school textbooks (Butcher & Hoosen, 2012).

...MOOCs, both cMOOCs and xMOOCs are a fascinating development. This essay has taken a critical stance because the discourse about MOOCs is overloaded with hype and myth while the reality is shot through with paradoxes and contradictions. However, an important process is underway that will chart new paths for the universities involved and for higher education generally.

...results of teaching quality assessments by discipline had accumulated over ten years a small former teachers? college ranked in the top ten (out of ~100) and the Open University was in 5th place, one above Oxford.

I think the author completely misses the idea that completion rates for paid courses are almost certain to be higher because of the financial commitment involved. (I'm sorry, but I consider this so obvious that I think a lack of acknowledgment of this point is an indicator of bias and making a "dishonest" argument)

I need to learn more about the UK Open University. One of the contributors on the Quantum Computing forums made multiple positive statements about it.

Despite some complaints, I think this paper is a great addition to the conversation. The list of references cited is overwhelming (and provides many leads for further reading).

Source: http://www.aiqus.com/questions/41231/making-sense-of-moocs-20-page-report-by-distinguished-he-distance-learning-educator

national signing day 2012 landon collins dorial green beckham mike kelly kristen bell colbert super pac colbert super pac

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.